Caro Claire Burke is the debut novelist behind one of the best time-travel books of recent years. If you’ve read it already, you know that this novel manages to be simultaneously a biting social satire and an exploration of performance, identity, and the quiet sacrifices women are asked to make to uphold tradition. It’s pretty difficult to find books that encompass all these topics at once, but our editors tried their best to choose titles you might like.

“Yesteryear strikes a nerve and keeps you guessing! It’s a timely commentary on the performativity of tradwife content and the lies we tell ourselves when we’re too scared to look at the truth. Sharp, insightful, and unputdownable ― I absolutely loved it!”

— Kateryna Dmytrychenko, AdvanceMe Team's editor

The Grace Year by Kim Liggett (2019)

When your grace year comes, you’re sent into the wilderness to expel the dangerous magic. Why is it so? Just because your village believes pubescent women possess that curse. Tierney is one of many girls who have to bear with this tradition. After this one year, girls come back to the village and assume their assigned roles as wives in an aggressively patriarchal community. Here, men hold total control over women’s lives, bodies, and fates. What is awaiting Tierney in the future?

“But a flower is never just a flower.”

— Kim Liggett, The Grace Year

Why fans of Yesteryear like it: Both novels place women inside social systems designed to break them. Both books surround women with an internal and external need for survival. The Grace Year shares Yesteryear’s interest in the performance of womanhood and the way patriarchal structures weaponize women against each other.

Yesteryear and all the books on this list are perfect for curious readers and deep thinkers. People like you would definitely appreciate AdvanceMe. It is our book summary app with a rich library of the most noteworthy nonfiction. Microlearning at its best: get the key insights on a variety of topics in just 10-15 minutes!

The Stepford Wives by Ira Levin (1972)

Joanna Eberhart and her family move from New York City to the quiet Connecticut suburb of Stepford. Her husband assures her that this place will be safer and better for the children. What Joanna finds instead is a town full of women who have been systematically transformed into smiling and endlessly accommodating versions of themselves. They are perfect housewives, uncomplaining and content, with no passion remaining.

“What’s the going price for a stay-in-the-kitchen wife with big boobs and no demands?”

— Ira Levin, The Stepford Wives

Why fans of Yesteryear like it: The Stepford Wives is arguably the original tradwife horror story. It’s a savage critique of the ideology that Natalie Heller Mills has built her empire on. Both books use dark comedy and horror to expose what “the ideal woman” really means for the women asked to become her.

Learn English with AdvanceMe:
Tradwife (also trad wife): a married woman, especially one who posts on social media, who stays at home doing cooking, cleaning, etc. and has children that she takes care of. Tradwife is short for traditional wife.

Heartwood by Amity Gaige (2025)

Inspired by a real 2013 disappearance on the Appalachian Trail, Heartwood follows Valerie Gillis. She is a nurse who sets out alone on a long-distance hike to push herself, find clarity, and rediscover her own sense of purpose. The narrative is a well-developed web of intersecting perspectives that gradually converge around Valerie’s fate. So, what is that fate after all?

“Some folks say, ‘Forgive yourself.’ But who the hell can do that? It’s a goddamned conflict of interest.”

— Amity Gaige, Heartwood

Why fans of Yesteryear like it: Heartwood is fundamentally about a woman stepping outside the life she has been assigned. In both novels, the environments are physically demanding and unfamiliar, but they force a woman to reckon with identity and what she’s expected to want.

Perfect Modern Wife by Kristen Van Nest (2025)

Just 60 pages, and you’ll know all the secrets of a wellness retreat run by a tradwife influencer. One single image from this novella captures the dark side of female perfection. Although Perfect Modern Wife isn’t a novel, it shows everything you need to know about being a so-called ideal wife. Are you ready for the truth?

Why fans of Yesteryear like it: If Yesteryear is the feature film, Perfect Modern Wife is the short, vicious short story sitting in the same universe. They both show a horror of tradwife culture, which at first seems inspirational.

Interesting fact: Van Nest grew up in the exact Connecticut suburb where the original Stepford Wives film was shot. Her perspective was further sharpened when her high school homecoming king married one of the country’s top tradwife influencers.

Bunny by Mona Awad (2019)

Events are happening at the fictional Warren University, where Samantha, a creative writing graduate student, is drawn into a circle of wealthy women who call each other “Bunny.” What she finds there is stranger, more violent, and more absurd than anything she could have anticipated. Plot twists in this novel will definitely make you gasp, worry, and rethink all your relationships.

“They laugh. What’s so fucking funny? I want to say. But I don’t. I laugh with them. Ha. Haha. Hahaha.”

— Mona Awad, Bunny

Why fans of Yesteryear like it: Bunny shares Yesteryear’s dark humor and deep interest in the performance of femininity. Both novels use the surreal and the absurd to say something precise about how women relate to one another under systems that pit them against each other.

Interesting fact: Awad has cited the work of Angela Carter and Shirley Jackson as influences. These two writers understood, as Burke clearly does, that the domestic and the monstrous are never very far apart.

The Handmaid’s Tale by Margaret Atwood (1985)

In the near-future theocratic republic of Gilead, women have been stripped of all legal rights. They have assigned roles, and their role in society is reduced to their biological functions. You will observe this world from Offred’s point of view. She is the narrator and a Handmaid — a woman of proven fertility assigned to bear children for a Commander and his wife. Is she there to break the system, or will the system break her?

“Better never means better for everyone... It always means worse, for some.”

— Margaret Atwood, The Handmaid’s Tale

Why fans of Yesteryear like it: The Handmaid’s Tale is the foundational text against which almost all tradwife fiction is now measured. It imagines with terrifying clarity what happens when the ideology behind the tradwife aesthetic is taken to its logical conclusion.

Half His Age by Jennette McCurdy (2026)

Half His Age follows seventeen-year-old Waldo, who becomes entangled in a toxic, deeply co-dependent relationship with her creative writing teacher, Mr. Korgi. The prose isn’t romanticized. McCurdy deliberately does it when depicting the relationship’s sexual dimensions. Raw, unglamorous writing is the best way to show the reality of grooming. McCurdy is known as the author of the memoir I’m Glad My Mom Died, and we have a summary you can read.

“‘Do you want me to move my hand?’ he asks. Yes, I think. ‘No,’ I say.”

— Jennette McCurdy, Half His Age

Why fans of Yesteryear like it: Both novels are interested in the gap between how a woman’s life looks and what it actually feels like from the inside. Yesteryear’s Natalie has built an empire on the performance of a life; Waldo is being shaped, in real time, into someone else’s ideal. Yes, they are a bit different, but reading Half His Age, you’ll have a slight sense of deja vu.

Interesting fact: McCurdy drew directly from her own experience of being in a relationship with a 30-year-old writer when she was eighteen.

Gone Girl by Gillian Flynn (2012)

On the morning of their fifth wedding anniversary, Amy Dunne disappears. All evidence points toward her husband, Nick, as the primary suspect. The novel has two layers of perspective: Nick’s present-day account and Amy’s diary entries from the years of their marriage. You see their relationship and ask yourself, “Do those people even know who they really are?” Perhaps, you’ve heard the famous “Cool Girl” monologue. It’s Amy’s furious dissection of the performance women put on for men, which remains one of the most quoted passages in contemporary fiction.

“Tampon commercial, detergent commercial, maxi pad commercial, windex commercial ― you’d think all women do is clean and bleed.”

— Gillian Flynn, Gone Girl

Why fans of Yesteryear like it: Gone Girl and Yesteryear are about the exhausting, suffocating performance of ideal womanhood. They show what happens when a woman decides she is done performing for a husband, the public, or eight million Instagram followers.

Interesting fact: The book is widely credited with launching the “Gone Girl Effect” — a wave of crime novels featuring the word “Girl” in the title and unreliable female antiheroes as protagonists.

Trad Wife by Saratoga Schaefer (2026)

This horror novel centers on Camille Deming, a tradwife influencer living on a beautiful farmhouse property. One day, she discovers a mysterious well behind her home and makes a wish for a child. What does she receive, and can she truly love it? The novel is an allegory for the way modern womanhood is being compressed into patriarchal definitions of the “good woman.” You won’t like the characters’ actions or words; even more, you’ll find them disgusting. Nevertheless, you’ll read it till the end because it is unputdownable.

“Maybe I don’t want to raise a traditional wife. Maybe I want to raise a feral woman.”

— Saratoga Schaefer, Trad Wife

Why fans of Yesteryear like it: Trad Wife and Yesteryear are perhaps the closest siblings on this list. However, while Yesteryear sends its protagonist backward in time to confront the reality beneath the fantasy, Trad Wife brings the horror directly into the farmhouse itself.

Interesting fact: The novel deliberately inverts the expected horror logic: Camille does not recoil from her grotesque child, but loves it completely and fiercely. The horror here isn’t that she has something unnatural. The horror is the system that made her want it so desperately in the first place.

---

What runs through every book on this list is a refusal to let the fantasy of the ideal woman go unexamined. We deeply hope that you’ve found a title for yourself on this list. If you know other books similar to Yesteryear, contact us at [email protected] and share your vision. Let’s help passionate readers together.